The Artist-Executive at Work: Coaching Creative Leaders
By Merritt Minnemeyer, PCC
The Creative Leader's Paradox
Creative leaders inspire fierce loyalty and occasional fantasies of mutiny - sometimes from the same people in the same week. Praised and maligned. Luminary and loner. Genius and total pain in the ass. The artist's life is as glamorous as it is cruel and unusual.
While romance attracts young optimists initially, those who stick around discover peaks and valleys that would seem untenable elsewhere but are simply how creatives engage with the everyday.
Crucially, artists learn to trust their intuition; it's how they navigate creative choices that can't be solved with logic alone. The starving artist trope loses its romance around, oh say, age 30. When that romance fades, so often does their connection to the intuition that once guided them. What happens then?
Some carry on, piecing together careers in the background. Others choose stability and health insurance, channeling their creative drive into quieter outlets. And then there are those who discover, often to their own surprise, they have the acumen to run the proverbial show in which they once aspired to perform.
The Artist-Executive
These become the leaders who hold the vision wherein artists can be seen, heard, and realized. They are the stewards of our culture. These are the artist-executives.
If you're a coach drawn to creative leaders, it's imperative to understand what makes this population unique. Artist-executives didn't climb a traditional corporate ladder. They emerged from creative practice into seats demanding a specialized skill set. They're navigating terrain that values both artistic integrity and commercial viability, often without a clear directive for how those two demands coexist.
Three Core Challenges
Here are the three core challenges artist-executives face—and how coaches can support their evolution
1. Staying True While Staying Solvent
Artist-executives handle daily decisions about where artistic vision bends to market realities and where it holds firm. Cast the bankable name or the unknown who's perfect for the role? Accept corporate sponsorship with strings attached or turn down desperately needed funding? These aren't abstract dilemmas—they're a typical Tuesday.
While artistic decisions often come from intuition, that intuition doesn't show up on a P&L statement. And boards want data, not hunches.
In coaching:
The client will bring a decision that sounds straightforward but is actually an identity crisis in disguise. "Should I hire this marketing VP?" could be "Am I becoming the kind of leader I swore I'd never be?"
Don't rush to problem-solving. The ontological work matters. Support them in reconnecting with their intuitive sense of rightness before building the rational framework. Then move to strategy; decision-making criteria that honor both artistic mission and organizational sustainability.

Tangible tactic:
Invite them to articulate non-negotiables in writing. Not vague values, but specific: "We will never _____ even if it means _____."
Here's the key: ask them to check these statements against their body, not just their brain. How do they know that it lands as true? What does their gut say?
Assist them in rebuilding the bridge between strategic thinking and creative knowing. Then offer to become the guardian of these commitments when future decisions test their resolve. And they will.
2. Leading Through Ambiguity Without Defaulting to Control
Artist-executives are often promoted for creative talent. They know how to make great work but are not necessarily trained how to create conditions for others to make great work. Nobody handed them a manual. (If someone did, they likely ignored it.)
The instinct can be overwhelming: just tell everyone what to do. Their vision has gotten them this far, and their aesthetic is the filter through which the whole organization may rise and fall. Watching others stumble, especially with money and reputation on the line, can be excruciating.
Micromanaging makes them bottlenecks. Their team's creativity atrophies because one person's vision can't match a talented team's collective intelligence, no matter how great the genius.
In coaching:
The client is drowning in decisions that shouldn't be on their desk. They're exhausted, their team frustrated—and possibly plotting that aforementioned mutiny.
The ontological work: Invite them to examine their relationship with control. What does it mean to be a leader versus a maker? Their identity as "the person who makes good things" is being called to evolve into "the person who makes it possible for good things to happen."

Tangible tactic: Implement decision tiers. Eg.
  1. Level 1: Team decides, no approval needed.
  1. Level 2: Team decides, leader informed after.
  1. Level 3: Collaborative decision.
  1. Level 4: Leader decides.
Start by moving just two decisions down a tier. Ask them to consider that delegating decisions isn't abandoning their creative instincts, but rather it's making room for those instincts to focus where they matter most.
Call them back to this structure when they inevitably default to old patterns under stress. (They will. Lovingly hold the line.)
3. Sustainable Pacing in a Volatile Industry
Creative industries glorify overwork and normalize crisis mode. The show must go on. The work is more important than the people who make it. We'll sleep when we're dead. Etc.
Artist-executives grew up in this culture, internalized it, and now perpetuate it, even as it slowly erodes them. They're not just burning the candle at both ends; they've invented a third end and lit that too.
The phrase "work-life balance" may make them roll their eyes. But their leadership clarity and decision-making quality are likely suffering for it. Most critically, their intuitive wisdom, their greatest leadership asset, goes offline when they're running on fumes.
In coaching:
The client cancels sessions because of a crisis. Then another. They are exhausted, depleted, and getting sick more often. When you mention rest, they look at you like you've suggested abandoning their post during battle.
The ontological work: Reframe rest as strategic advantage, and essential component of their brilliance, not moral failing. Their intuitive clarity is renewable, but only if they actually renew it.

Tangible tactic:
Identify their "non-negotiable renewal" activities—the things that actually restore them. Not just bubble baths (unless that works for them). The activities that reconnect them to their creative source: the museum visit, the afternoon with a novel, the jam session with friends. The stuff that made them artists in the first place.
Schedule these first, not last.
Artist-executives tend to commit to renewal aspirationally then sacrifice it the moment pressure rises. Part of our role is to remind them of who they are and to stay true to that, even when it is easy to abandon.
The Bottom Line
Artist-executives need finely tuned-in coaches who understand their challenges aren't about better time management. They're about identity, creative integrity, and navigating impossible tensions, often with no clean resolution.
They need someone who recognizes that artistic intuition is both their superpower and sometimes their obstacle when leading others.
They need accountability partners who won't flinch when called in to referee the ongoing battle between their creative vision and their operations app.
By honoring both the art and the business, the vision and the spreadsheet, coaches in this space can be invaluable to those who are on the front lines of stewarding our culture in a time when it is most vital to protect and grow it.
They need you. Now more than ever.
Merritt Minnemeyer
Merritt Minnemeyer partners with entertainment executives, arts innovators, and visionary entrepreneurs to accelerate vision and fully embody executive excellence. As Founder of Master of One Coaching, LLC she channels 25 years of leadership experience, her background in performance and production, and entrepreneurial DNA into guiding leaders who steward culture at the intersection of artistic vision and business imperatives.
A Professional Certified Coach (PCC) and NYU/Tisch graduate, Merritt holds a Masters of Professional Studies and specialized coaching certifications. After rebuilding her life following the loss of her husband, father, and grandfather in a single devastating year, she emerged with profound conviction: conscious creative leaders are essential to our thriving future. She believes those at the helm of influential organizations hold the exciting responsibility to create experiences that redefine what's awesome about being alive —shaping our world through creative courage, strategic sophistication, and humanity-centered leadership.
Advertise with The Coaches' Chronicle
Click image to discover how to place your premium ad in The Coaches' Chronicle
Subscribe to The Coaches' Chronicle
Click the image above to subscribe to 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝑪𝒐𝒂𝒄𝒉𝒆𝒔' 𝑪𝒉𝒓𝒐𝒏𝒊𝒄𝒍𝒆 for free and never miss an issue!